A Little Shopping, by Cynthia Rylant, for MMGM, and GIVEAWAY winner announced!

In yet another shout-out to the younger MG crowd, I’m spotlighting A Little Shopping, by Cynthia Rylant, which is the second book in her Cobble Street Cousins series.

A Little Shopping cover

These little books, for just-reading-independently kids, are the often overlooked bridge by which young readers cross over into the larger story land of Mossflower, The Penderwick sisters, and Harry Potter, and on occasion I like to swivel the spotlight around to shine on them.

But first, we have a winner to announce!  The lucky entrant who won last week’s giveaway of This Little President is–

JOANNE FRITZ!

I’ll send you an email so I can pass your info on to Joan, Joanne!  And, I’ll try to refrain from chuckling over that name pairing, as I do so… 😉  Thank you to everyone who entered or commented, for supporting Joan in her giveaway!  Thank you to Joan, too, for the lovely interview as well as the free copy of her book!

Now, on to this week’s spotlight of A Little Shopping.  The key for me when considering a book like this is two parts.  First off, I try to put myself in the shoes of the intended audience.  Would the book appeal?  Would they be able to read it?  Would it challenge them in appropriate ways?  The answer to all of these questions is yes, which of course is why I chose it for a spotlight!  I’m not an expert in these things, so I can’t speak to it’s lexicon ranking, but the book appears very well placed to me.

The second question which I think it’s helpful to ask ourselves is, could the adult readers who will be called on to help the child sound out words, or sit beside the child as they read, stomach the book, as well?  This is trickier, of course, since the mileage between readers is wider.  However, I think many adults harbor secret wishes, from their own childhood, and books that tap into this universal kid will be more successful.  Humor is another must, but of course needs to fit the book.  And finally, it doesn’t hurt if the book is sending unspoken messages that parent’s and teachers are themselves trying to reinforce.  Hopefully these can be done in a subtle way, so the reader doesn’t feel talked down to, or that they’ve been preached a sermon.  Done right, these contextual messages will simply slip into the readers minds, reinforcing a positive world view.  They can also provide a conversation starter, between young readers and/or the adults in their lives.

So, how did A Little Shopping do?  Once again, to my mind it did very well!  The premise that the three girls parents’ are off on tour in a world class ballet troupe may be a bit unrealistic, but it’s inventive and speaks to all of our desires to do what we really love, when we grow up, rather than settling and giving up on our dreams.  Similarly, the girls staying with their aunt who owns a flower shop may be a bit of wish-fulfillment for young girls, but also suggests a positive image that girls can grow up to own their own business.  As for the Cobblestone Cousin’s themselves, who are a bit one dimensional, they at least also represent various ‘types’ of girls, with Tess hoping to be a Broadway star (rather like their parents), while Lily wants to be a famous (or starving, take your pick) poet.  Rosie’s dreams are a little closer to home and involve a cottage with flowers around the door and lots of fabric to use in crafty ways, which is kind of refreshing.  Are any of the girls hoping to be scientists or doctors?  No, and neither are there any people of minorities, either.  It would be lovely if the books addressed these issues!  So, my marks for the book–so far–are tempered by its being set in a somewhat stereotyped, majority focused world.  Which brings us to humor.  On first glance, it would be easy to miss it since this wasn’t the kind of story where kids were snorting milk.  Truth, it’s unlikely the readers will be in stitches as they read, and smiles are more likely than outright laughter.  However, the story painted a bright mental picture and had just enough situational humor to add a little spice.  More importantly, the humor suited the book.

Now, let’s see what Apricot-kitty thought of it:

???????????????????????????????“I think this story was exactly like a soft bed in the sun.  Remarkable precisely because you can forget about why it’s remarkable and just enjoy it.”

 

 

 

 

And that sums up well the reason this series works!  This is a fleeting time in a young reader’s life, and the individual interests of the kids plus their skill levels make it hard to group them together.  I’m guessing the books have to redefine niche audience, and are therefor probably pretty challenging to write.  But, this little book shows three ingenious girls creating a lovely gift for their aunt while keeping themselves entertained, and does it in a handful of words and a slim page set, while making it look easy.  No mean feat!

Tell me what you’re reading in the comments, and share your thoughts!  Be sure to stop by Shannon Messenger’s blog, as well, for more Marvelous Middle Grade Monday spotlights, reviews, interviews and giveaways.  And happy reading!

MMGM2

 

Share, share away:

17 Comments

      • Tara, I completely agree with your motto! Which is why I'm glad I figured a way to mitigate it. You know what's the best thing? We managed to make the trasnfers in the space of one day – just met after work and exchanged stuff.

  1. Reply

    I think the title could draw girls in that like to shop, even though that’s not what the story is about. Glad you felt the story did what it was supposed to.

    • Reply

      It’s cute, isn’t it? And the girls actually do a bit of shopping at a fun little store I wouldn’t mind visiting, myself!

  2. Reply

    Suzanne,
    So happy to see you share a little love for this particular series, and this category of books. Too often young readers skip this phase ( or attempt to) and find themselves swimming in the deep end without out the confidence they once felt, often faking it rather than really reading deeply. I agree with kitty, there is much value in reading at a comfort level while you let life catch up with you. The characters are a delight and the stories are engaging enough to build complex processing in a natural and. Developmental way. Great spotlight!!

    • Reply

      Thanks, Sandy! I feel the same way about many of the picture books out there–shorter stories can still address complex themes, and young readers are really best off reading whatever stage fits them!

  3. Reply

    I’m always searching for recommendations for MG readers just getting started. This one sounds perfect. I’ll keep in in mind. Since you asked… I’m currently reading PAX, a story about a boy and his red fox.

    • Reply

      Oh, I think I’ve got PAX somewhere on my list! I look forward to your review, assuming you get to it before I do. 🙂

  4. Reply

    Oh, what a nice surprise! I’m honored to win Joan Holub’s book. Thank you!

    I haven’t read this particular Cobblestone Cousins book, but I’ve read a few of them. Cynthia Rylant is an amazingly-productive author. No, the books aren’t exactly diverse but my kids and I always enjoyed the Henry and Mudge series, and the Mr. Putter and Tabby series. As a bookseller, I tried to nudge customers toward the easy chapter book section when their kids weren’t quite ready for MG.

    • Reply

      I am right there with you in loving the Henry and Mudge books, too! And I really think it’s so wise for kids to build that solid foundation first! They’ll enjoy the ‘big books’ so much more if they do.

  5. Reply

    This one sounds like a great story! I love the cover, too. (To answer your question–er comment thingy—I just finished “Wonder” (it’s a great book!) and am currently reading “Fish In A Tree”.) Thanks for the review! 🙂

  6. Reply

    Ah, this sounds sweet. Just the kind of book I would’ve loved as a child, since I once had dreams of being a ballerina. I especially liked the cover. Your description reminded me of the Betsy-Tacy-Tib books.

  7. Reply

    Interesting, the characters sound more traditional thatn those in Mr. Putter and Tabby. Glad you liked this one as I feel there are not enough good books at the easy reader level.

    • Reply

      I’m realizing that I’ve got more reading to do, because I’m not familiar with Mr. Putter and Tabby (or Betsy-Tacy-Tib, for that matter), but thankfully reading is something I’m happy to dig in to!

Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *