An Open Letter to Utahns Re: Racism

I shared this post on Facebook, where somewhere around half of my friends are from Utah or grew up there, but I invite my blog readers to read this as well since I know the problem of racism is by no means limited to Utah, or any other region. Since this began life on FB it may read a little oddly here, but I want it to be widely available and not limited to FB users.

Here’s the thing…Utah has a racism problem—and I find it even more troubling than what I’ve seen in the South.

I was raised in Utah by rabidly racist parents who are so toxic I cut off contact with them ten years ago. I am intimately familiar with the hard work required to scrub off layers of racial prejudice, and concerned that too many of my fellow Utahns—and those with Utah roots—are not doing this challenging work. In fact, many Utahns are quick to assert that they’re not racist, and provide examples or ‘proof’ to back them up: They have black friends who aren’t offended by the things they say or do. They served a mission in a country with predominantly brown people, and came to love those they served. Maybe they’ve even participated in a civil rights protest.

These examples are shared as if those things can provide us with an ‘I’m not racist’ award we can hang on a wall and point to if our behavior is ever called into question. In truth it’s my opinion that as whites living in the US and benefiting as we do from a system that has been biased in our favor for hundreds of years, we have inherited a predisposition toward racism and prejudice that is built into our cultural DNA. The question is not: are we racist. The question is: are we working on it. Because just as I can carry a genetic predisposition for heart disease or diabetes but through hard work and daily dedication can avoid the disease, we can also do the daily work of overcoming this bias or predisposition toward racism. But the hard work can only begin if we’re willing to acknowledge there’s a problem.

So I ask you, my fellow Utahns, are you willing to admit you have a racism problem? Having spent twenty years in Utah and twenty between VA and NC, I freely acknowledge that Utah’s racism is generally more subtle than the racial problems of the south, where confederate statues and confederate flag-waving members of the KKK shove the issue into everyone’s faces. Utah is predominantly ‘Mormon’ and despite some troublesome church history regarding race the majority of members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints are genuinely trying to be decent human beings. We embrace kindness, take time for family, jump at the chance to serve, and tell everyone God loves them. In hundreds of big and small ways we work to improve ourselves and try to become better disciples of Christ. The idea that despite all that we could still be guilty of racism is often offensive and gets a knee-jerk rejection.

The numbers back it up, though—Utah has a racism problem. Don’t believe me? Check out this small sampling of links—I’ll wait.
Where black people are most disproportionately killed by police–Utah is last/worst.
A social listening study on ethnic slurs.
The first hand experience of Charlotte Lartey (with many thanks for her courage in sharing this!).

A problem of this magnitude does not exist in isolation. For racism to be widespread and systemic it requires not only the rabidly racist folks who are quick to use the n word and even defend its use, but also latent racists, who stay silent when faced with this ugliness. Perhaps the most telling tick I’ve noted as an identifier of this second group is that latent racists have a knee-jerk defensive response when it’s suggested that there could be a problem. If that makes you squirm and you’d like to explore further, here are some other signs that indicate there’s work to be done:

  • If during these protests you’ve shaken your head over the footage of looters, but have yet to watch the entirety of the video showing George Floyd’s murder, there’s work to be done.
  • If you get all your news from predominantly-white sources, without listening to and/or reading what black people have to say, there’s work to be done.
  • If you respond to ‘black lives matter’ with ‘all lives matter’ than you’ve definitely not understood the questions—let alone the answers, and there’s work to be done.
  • If the books you read are all or almost all by white authors, there’s work to be done. I know of no better way to get a glimpse inside someone else’s experience than through books. If you’d like to grow your shelf to include POC, The Brown Bookshelf is my first go-to for books that help me get outside my own life experience.
  • If in your private thoughts you believe that your black friend(s) is an exception to their race, and/or that black people who experience prejudice and complain about unfair law enforcement have done something to bring the problem on themselves, there’s work to be done.
  • If you think combating racism is a ‘one and done’ battle, or only something that happens in other places or used to happen, there’s work to be done.
  • If you think black people become more beautiful, more trustworthy, more capable, the more ‘white’ they make themselves in their outward appearance, there’s work to be done.

I could go on, and could also list the big obvious indicators of racism but I suspect most of us can identify those. I also suspect I’m going to get a lot of push-back for this post, and once again be told to ‘check myself.’ To which I answer thank you—I will. We should all be checking ourselves for symptoms of racism. I know for me this battle will likely by life-long, and as a gray-haired granny I’ll still need to be watchful. But I believe that only as we—each and every one of us—do this hard work can we heal our nation from the cancer of racism. I also know it will be worth it, and that our brown brothers and sisters deserve it. In truth, we all do. Because who really wants to live with cancer and make no real effort to cure it?

Honestly? These are mostly baby steps, but if you’ve made it this far I thank you for your willingness to open your mind to the possibility that there’s work to be done. Perhaps like me you’re already determinedly working to address it. Either way, I’m happy to journey with you. I also have to thank my many friends who’ve shared posts and helped me collect my thoughts. I learn from you and am grateful for the chance to grow.

And finally, I’ve included a cat pic because I’d really like this post to be read widely and there’s nothing better than a cat pic for that. This is Heimdall, who is at risk for developing diabetes and had to endure a weigh-in this week. You see? Even a Nordic cat god can’t shirk the work.

Please boost visibility for this post with a share or comment—I welcome civil and courteous discussion that speaks to the spirit in which the post was shared. Thank you!

Share, share away:

8 Comments

  1. Reply
    • Reply

      Thank you so much for sharing the link! I’ll go watch it. And thank you for commenting… I really believe the more the better when it comes to this conversation. <3 <3

  2. Reply

    Thanks, Suzanne. This is an important post with things we must all think about. I don’t think of myself as racist, but I am working on being a better person about race because I think most people of my age who grew up in a largely white world don’t recognize such things in ourselves. Myself included. My daughters are helping me find good resources and getting me to think about the work I need to do. I appreciate the good links you included. I have much to learn. I grew up in the Minneapolis area and always thought of it as such a nice place. My sister sent me an interesting link: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2020/06/george-floyd-protest-minneapolis-history-racism-minnesota/612481/

    • Reply

      Hugs, Rosi. I have quite a few friends with a bit more gray in their hair than mine who’ve really struggled with this, and I’m so proud of them when it starts to click. You are doing awesome work! Honest conversations and a willingness to learn are how we’ll get there. And thank you for the link–I look forward to reading it! <3 <3 <3

  3. Reply

    Thanks for posting this and sharing your experience, Suzanne. I am so sorry that you had to cut off ties with your family. Yes, this is something that we have to all work on. I grew up in Benton Harbor that became a ghost town in the 60’s and 70’s when whites fled across the river and there were riots in my high school. The difference between Benton Harbor and St. Joseph is even worse now. It feels like we haven’t made all that much progress, and I’m hoping some real good comes out of all these protests.

    • Reply

      Thank you for the sympathy, and I hope this movement can bring real change as well! Our communities need all of us and we need to somehow make this ugliness stop.

  4. Reply

    What a great and important post. I think many people are having tough conversations with loved ones. I know I have been working on some family members who are not understanding BLM and white privilege. I try to remain calm and provide facts. But it is hard to undo that “one news station” they watch. Baby steps are better than no steps. I am learning every day and I still have a lot of work to do. It seems like I am constantly learning about new things in history that I was not taught and that change my views on things. So many parts of systemic racism are hidden under the surface and I think some people are afraid to look.

    Sorry to hear about cutting off ties with your family- but I also understand. It can be hard to realize that people you love are racist and not willing to change. Good luck with your journey. 🙂

    • Reply

      Thank you so much for the support! I have other family (besides my parents) who’re more willing to grow and less toxic, and I’m grateful to see some progress there. And then in the end it’s really most important that we work on ourselves, and as you say, be willing to take a hard look at things that’ve been kept hidden. Here’s to doing that, and good luck on your journey!

Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *